Looking at this geeklist, the following thoughts popped into my head.
- Ameritrash is apparently like pornography .... in that you can only define it by knowing it when you see it. That, and occasionally inappropriate plastic. (Survive is Ameritrash? Really?)
- Apart from linguistic games, I can't argue with the list. I've played almost every single title (or tried to, in the case of Magic Realm ... and I briefly owned a copy).
- The two games I haven't played are entirely due to lack of access (Space Hulk and Tales of the Arabian Nights), and I'm undoubtedly playing the latter when I get a chance. And the former just announced a reprint...
- That being said, I won't play a few of the games anymore. Despite Peter's withering attack on Talisman, I enjoyed playing it at one time, but a recent game reminded me why I stopped. It was fine, until the expansions started coming out. I've been actively avoiding Junta for a few years.
- Dune has never done anything for me, but I recognize I'm in the minority.
- I'm with the commenters — where the hell is BloodBowl. Football? Check. Plastic, check. Dice, check, violence, check. Lots of chrome, check. And mate. Still, the list hasn't been invented that doesn't have at least one glaring "Where is that" and one "WTF, mate?", so one or two omissions are expected. (BloodBowl is over 20 years old, I think). Illuminati (as "Beer and Pretzel classics") probably belong as well.
My nodding sagely is partially due to my intro to gaming. (The first games I played as a freshman were Cosmic, Wiz-War, Kremlin, Talisman and Junta, with a game of Titan that confused me to death). I guess I got lucky that my first game group only played a few games ... they settled for classics. Just something to consider when introducing new players to gaming.