The Tao of Gaming

Entering the Top 20 ... I like games, really!


Mu & Mehr hits the Top 20. I'd be surprised to see a higher ranked card game. I loved it for a long time, but eventually came around to the view (first expressed to me by Jeff Goldsmith) that there are too many trumps (potentially) and the suits are a bit too short. I haven't played in years, but as I rarely play card games, that's not surprising. [Really, the only one I remember suggesting in years is Flauschentuefel].

Medici [#19]. Ok, I would have been tempted to put this in my Top 15. It's an '8' right now. [I rate 12 games a '10' or '9', and 26 games an '8']. I don't think I'd vote for it, but I'd regret skipping over it. Just how many games does Reiner have in the Top 100?

I'm a Crokinole [#18] well-wisher, in that I wish it no specific harm. [I just wanted to use that line]. It's a fine game. I haven't sprung for a board, but I don't have a problem playing. I've had one good run at it, but I'm mediocre.

Time's Up, by Peter Sarrett shows up at #17. My favorite party game. Peter ignored me when I told him that he should turn Celebrities into a TV gameshow, going for the board game route. Just goes to show how ignoring me pays off. I normally just play Celebrities, because I like a) seeding the bag, b) multiple copies of the same name appearing (or having that possibility), c) some names are trademarked, so don't appear in tha published game. [But I do own the game, Peter!].

Incidentally, for a long time we went through a 'theme' phase (where all the names we put into the bag would have a theme). That got old faster than you'd imagine. Subtle themes can work, though.

No problems with Union Pacific at #16, either. I should toss it into the bag again. Say ... does anyone have the rules for the updated (newer) setup? I seem to recall that they changed (at least for the Gathering tournies)?

Larry Levy (mail):

Mu &Mehr hits the Top 20. I'd be surprised to see a higher ranked card game.

Welcome to old age, Brian. I'm assuming you're having a senior moment, or else you're just smoking the crack, because you KNOW that Tichu has to make the Top 100, and if it hasn't appeared yet, it'll be in the Top 15. (I'm not saying that because I think Tichu is one of the 15 best games ever, just that there are so many players who are huge fans who WILL put it in their Top 15 lists.)
11.13.2005 2:56am
Brian (www):
I said card game, not cardboard drug. But yeah, I forgot Tichu. I was pretty sure that I had typed "Traditional" card game, to make sure that I also covered Magic and other games. Sadly, climbing games are traditional.

As a curmudgeon, I'm grooming myself for advanced age, where that kind of behavior is expected.
11.13.2005 9:13am